In the field of industrial construction such as workshop design & workshop construction, choosing the right materials and construction methods is a key factor, determining the efficiency, cost and progress of the project. The two most popular solutions today are prefabricated steel workshops and reinforced concrete workshops. Each type has its own advantages and disadvantages, suitable for each specific purpose and conditions. This article will analyze and compare in detail these two types of workshops in many aspects, from design, construction, cost to application, helping customers have an overview and make the optimal choice.
COMPARISON OF PREFABRICATED STEEL WORKSHOP AND REINFORCED CONCRETE WORKSHOP
Prefabricated steel workshop
Pre-engineered steel workshop is a type of workshop that is prefabricated at the factory, including main components such as steel frames, beams, columns, purlins, roofing panels... Then, these components are transported to the construction site for assembly. This process helps save time, labor and ensures quality.
Reinforced concrete workshop
Reinforced concrete workshop is a traditional type of workshop, using concrete and steel as the main materials to build the entire structure. The components are cast in place according to the design drawings, requiring longer construction time and a more complicated process.
Detailed comparison of criterias for prefabricated steel workshops and reinforced concrete workshops
1. Design and construction process
| Criteria |
Prefabricated steel workshop |
Reinforced concrete workshop |
| Design |
- Simple and fast design.
- Use specialized software for calculation.
- Standard structure, easy to change. |
- Complex design, requires details.
- Structural calculations are more complex.
- Difficult to change after design. |
| Construction |
- Factory fabrication: Prefabricated components.
- Site assembly: Fast assembly process, less affected by weather.
- Progress: Construction progress is shortened by 30-50% compared to concrete houses.
|
- Construction at site: Pouring concrete, installing steel reinforcement on site.
- Progress: Longer, depends a lot on the weather.
- Labor: Requires many highly skilled workers. |
2. Investment costs
| Criteria |
Prefabricated steel workshop |
Reinforced concrete workshop |
| Materials |
- Steel, corrugated iron...
- Material costs are often higher than concrete. |
- Concrete, steel, sand, stone, cement...
- Lower initial material costs.
|
| Labor |
- Concrete, steel, sand, stone, cement...
- Lower initial material costs.
|
- Many workers, long construction time.
- High labor costs. |
| Total cost |
- Total initial investment costs are often lower due to savings in labor costs and time. |
- The total initial cost is higher due to labor costs and longer construction time. |
Note: Costs also depend on the scale, geographic location and technical requirements of the project.
3. Durability and load bearing capacity
| Criteria |
Prefabricated steel workshop |
Reinforced concrete workshop |
| Durability |
- Withstands heavy loads. Durable over time.
- Prone to corrosion, requires regular maintenance. |
- Strong, good bearing capacity.
- Corrosion resistant, low maintenance.
|
| Bearing capacity |
- Steel structures have good tensile, compressive and bending resistance.
- Can build factories with large spans and large spaces.
|
- Concrete has good compressive strength, steel has good tensile strength.
- Suitable for high-rise buildings, with heavy loads.
|
| Safe |
- Fire resistance: Less, special fire protection layer is required.
- Labor safety: Higher due to factory construction, less risk at construction site.
|
- Fire resistance: Better.
- Labor safety: Lower due to complex construction at the site. |
|
4. Applicability and flexibility
| Criteria |
Prefabricated steel workshop |
Reinforced concrete workshop |
| Flexibility |
- Easy to expand: Can be disassembled, moved, and installed.
- Change function: Easy to change internal structure.
|
- Difficult to expand: Difficult to change structure, expansion is complicated and expensive.
|
| Reuse |
- High Reusability: Components can be dismantled and reused for other projects.
- Environmentally friendly: Minimizes construction waste.
|
- Difficult to reuse: Concrete waste is difficult to handle. |
CHOOSE PRE-ENGINEERED WORKSHOP OR REINFORCED CONCRETE WORKSHOP?
The choice between prefabricated steel workshops and reinforced concrete workshops depends on many factors:
In summary, prefabricated steel workshops offer many outstanding advantages in terms of construction progress, cost, flexibility and reusability. On the contrary, reinforced concrete workshops have advantages in terms of durability, fire resistance and longevity. Careful consideration of the above factors will help investors make wise decisions, ensuring economic efficiency and project quality.
SVG ENGINEERING – A REPUTABLE FACTORY DESIGN UNIT WITH 20 YEARS OF EXPERIENCE
SVG Engineering is a leading reputable and affordable factory design unit in Vietnam, trusted and chosen by many domestic and foreign enterprises for many years. With a team of dedicated, experienced and knowledgeable architects and construction engineers, we are committed to providing optimal design solutions, saving costs and ensuring functionality.
SVG Engineering designs a variety of factory types such as prefabricated steel buildings & reinforced concrete buildings, warehouses, food, footwear, mechanical, garment factories... according to the actual requirements of each enterprise. In addition, we always update a new transparent price list every year, dedicated consulting and committed design progress are the reasons that help SVG Engineering become a reliable partner for every project.
IMAGES OF COMPLETED FACTORY DESIGN PROJECTS IN USE OF SVG ENGINEERING
COST OF WORKSHOPS DESIGN IN VIETNAM
Please immediately contact Hotline: 0902.593.686 (Mr. Thang) & Email: svg.engineer@gmail.com for support and advice on issues related to Workshop Design in Viet Nam ... Best regards!
VietNam construction consulting - Mr. Thang 0902.593.686
CONTACT US:
SAO VIET CONSTRUCTION DESIGN CONSULTING AND INSPECTION JOINT STOCK COMPANY
🏢 Hai Phong Office :
Address : 7th floor SVG Building - Bui Vien Street - An Bien Ward - Hai Phong City
☎ Tel: (0225) 3.747.819
📞 Hotline: 0902.593.686
📧 Email: svg.engineer@gmail.com
🌎 VietNam Website: giamsatcongtrinh.com
🌎 English Website: en.giamsatcongtrinh.com
🌎 China Website: cn.giamsatcongtrinh.com
Youtube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/@svgengineering
🏢 Representative offices:
- Ha Noi Branch Office : No. 9/ 81 Hoang Cau Street, Dong Da Ward, Hanoi Capital
- Ho Chi Minh Branch Office: 2/1C Cao Thang Street, Ban Co Ward, Ho Chi Minh City
- Hue Branch Office : M25 Lot , 21 Street, Dong Nam Thuy An, Thanh Thuy Ward, Hue City